Hmm. Before I learned about the pros and cons of declawing, I had my cat declawed. My goal was that he would be — from that day forward — 100% indoors. One day, as my husband slammed the French door shut to keep Tyler buddy inside, Tyler shot through the door but 1” of his tail didn’t make it. Fortunately, it was just bruised but we were done fighting him. Tyler is now a happy indoor/outdoor cat. He climbs trees, hunts, brings home presents all the time (some are still alive ).
So, originally, I wouldn’t have thought so, but it works for Tyler Buddy. Had I done it all over, I’d have started him on a catawhack unit and wouldn’t have the concern. Now, if your feline friend has already had all four feet declawed, NO WAY! In that case, they really can’t go outside and that’s pretty darn harsh!
Many years ago my husband brought home an one-year old pure black, half-Siamese cat named, Munch. His original family had already had his front claws removed, which my husband considered a plus at the time, though I never would have allowed one of the cats we’ve had to be declawed. He happily played in our backyard including chasing any strange cats away. He was still very good at tree climbing and hunting, including bringing inside a live bird that I was able to release undamaged fortunately. We ended up having to put a bell around his neck to help protect the local bird population.
My, albeit limited, understanding is that the front claws are essential in fending off aggressive dogs. Without the front claws to swat a tender nose and face, a dog or group of dogs can easily overpower and kill a cat with no claws. Swatting and stunning an aggressor animal can give kitty time to make a break for safety.